Columnists

US podcast misinformation goes largely unchecked

Misinformation about everything from election fraud to Covid-19 vaccines is reaching millions of Americans through a popular but opaque medium: podcasts.

Many podcasts, on-demand audio programmes that users can listen to on smartphones, promote false and unproven claims.

The Brookings Institution found War Room from former Donald Trump aide Steve Bannon has aired the most false statements, amassing more than 135 million downloads while promoting allegations of vote rigging in the 2020 United States election.

Commentator Joe Rogan, whose podcast is the most popular on Spotify, has also used his platform to push unproven Covid-19 treatments.

Analysts say people seek out the shows that reaffirm their own beliefs. But the intimate, conversational format also helps enable the spread of misinformation.

"There's something inherent to the relationship between a host and the audience that lends this level of credibility, this level of trust," Valerie Wirtschafter, a senior data analyst who led the Brookings research, told AFP.

"And the challenge, of course, is that anybody can be a podcaster, anybody can get a microphone and start talking about whatever they want."

Wirtschafter's team analysed 36,000 episodes and found 70 per cent of the most popular US podcasts had shared at least one claim debunked by fact-checkers.

Many cast doubt on the 2020 election or the coronavirus pandemic.

Unlike social media platforms, podcasts offer little or no opportunity for listeners to comment or push back on misinformation.

This "makes it easier for false, misleading, or unsubstantiated content to spread with little oversight", Brookings researchers said in their February report.

Rogan took down an episode in January after he discussed a fake tweet about Covid-19 vaccines that was falsely attributed to a Florida doctor.

But such a move is rare, and Wirtschafter said moderation is "really complicated" for technology companies.

A Pew Research Center study published in April found about half of Americans listen to podcasts, and 87 per cent say they expect the information to be accurate, representing a higher level of trust than other media.

"The relationship with the host is different," said Sylvia Chan-Olmsted, director of media consumer research at the University of Florida.

"It's like having a one-on-one conversation; you feel this person is talking to you.

"People trust it more, and that's why it's more impactful."

Another podcast cited by Brookings is one of Apple's top news commentary programmes from conservative activist Charlie Kirk, who has falsely claimed athletes are dying from Covid-19 vaccines and that election officials in Arizona manipulated 2020 results.

Rogan, Bannon and Kirk did not respond to requests for comment.

Responding to podcast misinformation is challenging because it is a decentralised, primarily audio-based ecosystem on multiple platforms with different moderation rules.

Spotify, for example, has a policy banning "dangerous" content but also seeks to "respect creator expression".

The company stood by Rogan in 2022 when he was accused of spreading coronavirus misinformation.

NewsGuard, a firm that rates the credibility of websites, announced in May it would begin evaluating the trustworthiness of popular podcasts.

NewsGuard said it will release the ratings for some 200 podcasts in 2024, giving more transparency to listeners and enabling advertisers to avoid podcasts featuring misinformation or content at odds with their brand.

Responsibility for countering podcast misinformation is murky, with some pointing to the hosting platforms or recommendation algorithms from tech giants like Apple, Google and Facebook.

Wirtschafter, the Brookings analyst, said governments, podcast hosts and listeners can work to improve information quality.

"Taking things down is maybe not the best solution.

"But adding more context, providing a richer environment so that people actually can explore evidence or have conversations would be useful."


The writer is from the Agence France-Presse news agency

Most Popular
Related Article
Says Stories